Beating Goliath: Why Insurgencies WinPotomac Books, 2007 - 180 pages Beating Goliath examines the phenomenon of victories by the weak over the strong--more specifically, insurgencies that succeeded against great powers. Jeffrey Record reviews eleven insurgent wars from 1775 to the present and determines why the seemingly weaker side won. He concludes that external assistance correlates more consistently with insurgent success than any other explanation. He does not disparage the critical importance of will, strategy, and strong-side regime type or suggest that external assistance guarantees success. Indeed, in all cases, some combination of these factors is usually present. But Record finds few if any cases of unassisted insurgent victories except against the most decrepit regimes. Having identified the ingredients of insurgent success, Record examines the present insurgency in Iraq and whether the United States can win. In so doing, Record employs a comparative analysis of the Vietnam War and the Iraq War. He also identifies and assesses the influence of distinctive features of the American way of war on the U.S. forces' performance against the Iraqi insurgency. Make no mistake: insurgent victories are the exception, not the rule. But when David does beat Goliath, the consequences can be earth shattering and change the course of history. Jeffrey Record's persuasive logic and clear writing make this timely book a must read for scholars, policymakers, military strategists, and anyone interested in the Iraq War's outcome. |
From inside the book
Results 1-3 of 36
Page 65
Why Insurgencies Win Jeffrey Record. greater superiority in political leadership ; and in Ulysses S. Grant and William Tecumseh Sherman , the Union - albeit belatedly - had military leadership that , like Lincoln , appreciated the war at ...
Why Insurgencies Win Jeffrey Record. greater superiority in political leadership ; and in Ulysses S. Grant and William Tecumseh Sherman , the Union - albeit belatedly - had military leadership that , like Lincoln , appreciated the war at ...
Page 66
... leadership ; ( 5 ) moral disquiet over the institution of slavery ; and ( 6 ) Lincoln's " malice toward none " approach to the defeated South.116 Antietam , not Gettysburg , was the strategically decisive battle of the war because it ...
... leadership ; ( 5 ) moral disquiet over the institution of slavery ; and ( 6 ) Lincoln's " malice toward none " approach to the defeated South.116 Antietam , not Gettysburg , was the strategically decisive battle of the war because it ...
Page 93
... leadership and are being raised and maintained separately from political authority - a major difference from South Vietnam , where , after the overthrow of the Diem regime in 1963 , the military leadership became the country's civil ...
... leadership and are being raised and maintained separately from political authority - a major difference from South Vietnam , where , after the overthrow of the Diem regime in 1963 , the military leadership became the country's civil ...
Contents
The Role of External Assistance | 23 |
Search and Destroy | 117 |
Conclusion | 131 |
Copyright | |
3 other sections not shown
Other editions - View all
Common terms and phrases
administration American Arab armed army attacks attempted battle believed British Bush casualties China Chinese civil colonies combat command committed Communist continued conventional conventional military costs counterinsurgency critical decisive defeat Defense democracies democratic determined direct effective enemy especially external assistance fact factors failed fight foreign France French ground guerrilla important Institute interests internal intervention involved Iraq Iraqi insurgency irregular John leadership less limited lose losses lost major material means militarily Nationalist never North numbers objectives observes operations organization outcome peace percent political population President protracted regime regular resistance side Small Wars South Vietnam Soviet Spanish strategy strength strong stronger Studies success Sunni superior supply tactical terrorism terrorist threat tion trained troops U.S. forces U.S. military Union United University Press victory Vietnamese Communists waging warfare Washington weak weaker weapons withdrawal World York